Top 12 states that dislike Tom Brady as Super Bowl analyst

Tom Brady’s illustrious career on the football field has left an indelible mark on the game, earning him both admirers and detractors across the United States. As the legendary quarterback transitions into his new role as a Super Bowl analyst, fans from various regions harbor mixed feelings about his presence in the commentary booth. This article delves into the specific grievances and lingering resentments from different states towards Brady, highlighting how his past achievements and controversies continue to stir emotions nationwide. Another breakdown, by the fine folks at BetOnline.ag, have a bit different deep dive that includes a cool state-by-state map (you’ll see it at the conclusion) showing which ones have the most Brady bashers to the least. Remember, fans weighed in wondering why he’s the NFL’s top-paid No. 1 commentator — not that he’s a bad person — although one did write on Twitter (X. OK, whatever, Elon) that Brady is “a horrible announcer.” BetOnline.ag’s map is based on geotagged X data in the past 90 days, tracking negative sentiment tweets about Tom Brady as an NFL announcer/commentator. For example, tracking all the tweets about Brady as a commentator in each state, and determining what percentage of those tweets was negative. For instance, “Tom Brady sucks as a commentator,” “Tom Brady is a boring commentator,” “Tom Brady is an awful announcer,” etc. Over 160,000 tweets were tracked. As you’ll from see from the map, the northeast (under the New England states) has the most negative opinion, followed by the Midwest and some southern states. It seems the area that is prime Steelers and Eagles territory dislikes Brady as an announcer most, which is unfortunate for Eagles fans, as Brady will be announcing Super Bowl LIX. Brady has improved over this last year in terms of his broadcasting abilities, however many viewers believe there are much better options, such as Greg Olsen, a former player and fan favorite announcer, who Brady replaced. Here are the top 12 states that think Brady is a horrible NFL announcer (based on percentage of negative tweets) and then you’ll see BetOnline.ag’s map and the breakdown for all 50 states. Let’s look at the top 12 states with football teams.

12. North Carolina: Panthers fans recall Super Bowl XXXVIII loss

Panthers fans in North Carolina harbor lingering resentment towards Tom Brady, stemming from their Super Bowl XXXVIII loss in 2004. Brady led the Patriots to a narrow 32-29 victory, crushing Carolina’s championship dreams. This painful memory resurfaces as Brady takes the analyst chair, reminding fans of their team’s heartbreaking defeat on the biggest stage.

11. Wisconsin: Packers loyalists defend Rodgers’ legacy

Packers fans in Wisconsin remain skeptical of Brady’s commentary, especially regarding Aaron Rodgers. Despite Rodgers’ departure to the Jets in 2023, many Cheeseheads still view him as a Packers legend. They worry Brady might downplay Rodgers’ achievements or unfairly compare their careers, given their historic rivalry.

10. Illinois: Bears fans prefer their own legends

Chicago Bears fans have little love for Tom Brady as a Super Bowl analyst. They prefer their own football legends like Mike Ditka and Dick Butkus. Brady’s success against the Bears (6-1 record) and his perceived arrogance don’t sit well with the passionate Windy City faithful.

9. Missouri: Chiefs kingdom’s new broadcasting nemesis

Kansas City fans are wary of Brady’s potential bias as he analyzes their team in Super Bowl LIX. With the Chiefs facing the Eagles, Missouri residents wonder what’s Brady’s commentary might be against his former AFC rival. The state’s skepticism stems from Brady’s controversial dual role as a Raiders minority owner and FOX analyst.

8. Florida: Dolphins supporters tired of AFC East dominance

Dolphins fans in Florida harbor resentment towards Brady due to his long-standing dominance in the AFC East, especially against Miami. The Bills have now won 12 of their last 13 meetings against Miami, continuing the trend of AFC East supremacy that Brady established during his Patriots tenure. This frustration extends to Brady’s new role as a Super Bowl analyst.

7. California: 49ers fans rue the “Tuck Rule” game

California, particularly 49ers fans, harbors resentment towards Brady. His controversial “Tuck Rule” play in 2002 against the Raiders still stings. Moreover, Brady’s repeated use of the disliked nickname “San Fran” during broadcasts has further alienated Bay Area viewers. Despite being from San Mateo, Brady’s commentary choices have irked his home state.

6. Georgia: Falcons faithful still bitter over Super Bowl LI

Georgia fans, especially Atlanta Falcons supporters, harbor deep resentment towards Brady for orchestrating the historic 28-3 comeback in Super Bowl LI. The painful memory of that 2017 loss still stings, making Brady’s presence as an analyst a constant reminder of their team’s epic collapse.

5. Pennsylvania: Steelers Nation’s longtime foe

Pennsylvania, home to the Pittsburgh Steelers, harbors deep-seated animosity towards Tom Brady. As a player, Brady dominated the Steelers, winning all three AFC Championship matchups and maintaining a 12-3 overall record against them. Now, as he prepares for his first Super Bowl as an analyst, Steelers fans remain wary of his presence in the broadcast booth.

4. Maryland: Ravens fans remember the rivalry

Ravens fans in Maryland harbor somewhat mixed feelings about Tom Brady as a Super Bowl analyst. Their intense rivalry during Brady’s Patriots years, including memorable playoff battles, still lingers. While some appreciate his expertise, others remain skeptical, recalling the contentious matchups and Brady’s 2-2 playoff record against Baltimore.

3. Indiana: Colts Country’s lingering Deflategate grudge

Indianapolis Colts fans still harbor resentment towards Brady due to the 2015 Deflategate scandal. The controversy, which began during a Colts-Patriots game, resulted in Brady’s suspension and continues to fuel animosity in Indiana. Brady’s new role as a Super Bowl analyst may rekindle these bitter memories for Colts supporters.

2. New York: Jets and Giants fans unite in disdain

New York football fans, both Jets and Giants supporters, have found common ground in their dislike for Tom Brady as a Super Bowl analyst. Brady’s recent jab at both teams during a Fortune Magazine interview, telling their fans to “shut up,” has only intensified the animosity. His history of defeating both franchises adds salt to the wound.

1. Massachusetts: From hero to villain

Once Brady’s home state, Massachusetts now leads the pack in anti-Brady sentiment. Fans still feel betrayed by his departure from the Patriots and subsequent success with Tampa Bay. His transition to broadcasting has only intensified the resentment, with many viewing his Super Bowl analysis as rubbing salt in the wound.

Conclusion

As Tom Brady embarks on his new journey in broadcasting, the echoes of his past successes and controversies remain palpable among fans across the nation. From lingering Super Bowl heartbreaks to longstanding rivalries, his presence as an analyst rekindles a spectrum of emotions. Whether viewed as a villain or a legendary figure, Brady’s influence on the sport extends beyond the field, shaping the narratives and passions of football aficionados in diverse corners of the country. This complex tapestry of sentiment underscores the lasting impact of his storied career. But this will be the most-watched Super Bowl in history. Book it. Why? Tom Brady is analyzing the game and Taylor Swift will be watching the game. Some people will tune in just to see the commercials, which cost advertisers a record-breaking $8 million per ad. That’s nothing for Brady but we know he values how we’ll be critiqued Sunday night after Super Bowl LIX.